A US federal judge has refused to throw out a proposed class action against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron over DRAM supply cuts. The plaintiffs accuse the three memory makers of coordinating those cuts, according to a Tom’s Hardware report published November 15. Their memory chips go into the phones, PCs and consoles whose prices have climbed alongside RAM costs. The ruling moves the DRAM price-fixing case toward discovery. It is not a finding that anyone colluded, and it changes no prices yet.

What the judge decided in the DRAM price-fixing case
Judge Noel Wise, who presides over the case in the Northern District of California, denied the chipmakers’ motion to dismiss. The companies had argued that the suit simply repeats a 2018 antitrust case brought against the memory industry. Wise rejected that argument because the plaintiffs showed some new evidence suggesting collusion.
Tom’s Hardware quotes the judge’s description of the plaintiffs’ claims:
Their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation — an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do.
Put simply, the court found the alleged pattern unusual enough to deserve a closer look. That is a long way from proof of a cartel.
What the plaintiffs allege
The suit was brought by 17 individuals and small businesses. They point to a series of parallel moves that they say restricted DRAM supply. They also say prices rose as much as 500% in one year. The conduct cited, as reported by Tom’s Hardware, includes:
- Production cuts: simultaneous DRAM output cuts from October 2022 to April 2023, followed by a shared pivot to high-bandwidth memory (HBM).
- DDR4 wind-down: all three companies announced the end of DDR4 within three months of each other.
- No new capacity: a failure to expand production even as prices hit extraordinary levels.
- Consumer exit: Micron shutting down its Crucial consumer brand.
- Tighter terms: refusing long-term contracts and vetting customers more strictly.
The chipmakers see it differently. They say these were logical business decisions made in their own independent interest. In their telling, the market is highly concentrated and all three are simply reacting to the same pressures. That is the companies’ position, and the court has not yet weighed it against the plaintiffs’ evidence. The plaintiffs’ claims are equally unproven at this stage.
What happens next
Both sides still have to present their evidence. The defendants must respond to the complaint by December 7, and a case management conference is set for January 2027.
For buyers, nothing changes right away. Memory costs are still feeding into device prices. Apple says memory costs will keep rising, and Counterpoint says average smartphone selling prices hit a record $442 in Q3. Don’t expect this ruling to reverse that trend. It does mean the three companies named in the suit must now answer the complaint and face discovery.
Source: Tom’s Hardware





